Reading Room Document

Application of Department of Justice Attorney to Argue Civil Rights Case for Private Plaintiffs

The document discusses the evaluation of Mr. A's application for leave to argue a civil rights case for private plaintiffs, in accordance with the Department's Standards of Conduct. Mr. A had requested leave to brief and argue the case after joining the Department, citing his unique qualifications and familiarity with the case. The conclusion reached is that while Mr. A was allowed to assist in preparing the brief, he was not permitted to participate in oral argument due to the absence of "unusual circumstances" that initially justified his involvement. The questions presented for review include whether a distinction should be drawn between preparing and signing the brief and participating in oral argument, as well as the possible impact on the Department if Mr. A argues the case, and the hardship to his former clients if he does not.

May 24, 1977