Essays & Scholarship

Foreword

An Illustrated Field Guide to Social Media

Ethan Zuckerman

December 13, 2022

Illustration of two parrots in a birdcage
Fiammetta Ghedini/RIVA Illustrations
Read time 4 min.

Sections

    Social media took center stage in discussions about U.S. politics and civic life during and after the 2020 presidential election. President Trump and his allies used Twitter and other tools to develop and advance the false narrative that the election had been stolen. Right-wing extremists organized on social media platforms to storm the U.S. Capitol on January 6 and briefly halted the official electoral vote count. Ultimately, Twitter and Facebook deplatformed the former president, sparking debates about the power these platforms have over speech online.

    Is social media increasing political polarization in the United States and in other nations? Are conspiracy theorists and movements like QAnon incubating on social platforms? Can the algorithms of social media drag unsuspecting users into extremism? In short, is social media bad for democracy?

    These are worthwhile questions, but they reflect a key blind spot. Because Facebook, Twitter, and YouTube are so prominent and are so widely amplified by mainstream media, we tend to assume that all social media operate in the same way and suffer from the same problems. This narrow view of social media not only limits our discussions about social media and its effects, it constrains our imagination about what social media could do or be. Our work on digital public infrastructures begins from the idea that we can build social media that works radically differently than Facebook, Twitter, and YouTube. Mapping the diverse range of social media “logics”—different ways social media can and does work—is proof positive that other worlds are possible.

    This field guide is the result of a year-long exploration of social media platforms and practices. We set out looking for social media that works on a different “logic” than Facebook, Twitter, or YouTube. This led us to examine communities that have tried consciously to use different models than surveillance capitalism, like the crypto logic community and the creators of decentralized platforms. It also led us to reach out to collaborators in other countries and subcultures, leading to essays on Chinese and Russian social media, as well as an essay on gift logic in fanfiction communities.

    We rely on the (partial, inadequate, and incomplete) indices of web-based popularity to identify other social media logics that surprised us with their popularity: question-and-answer platforms and forum-type social networks, for example. Our deep dive into the popularity rankings of social media reveals logics we’ve not yet written about, like social networks designed for the workplace. They also remind us that the landscape is ever-shifting, with networks like TikTok cementing their popularity during the time of our study, forcing us to ask whether our categories need to expand to encompass new dimensions: Is a social network where you don’t primarily follow friends a social network? Are algorithmically directed social networks their own thing, or are all social networks algorithmically directed to one extent or another?

    This field guide is not just an invitation to look, but to discover: new social media logics, new ways of classifying or talking about social networks.

    It is important for us to disclaim—early and often—that this guide, originally published on the Knight First Amendment Institute’s blog, is far from comprehensive. Not only are there logics we have not written about, there are logics we have not been smart enough to discern. The lines we’ve drawn are also not definitive. We don’t believe that an ideal set of categories to understand social media is possible, and even if it were, we would have no reason to believe these are the correct categories. We use these categories because they allow us to talk about social media in different ways, acknowledging different combinations of business models, technical affordances, communities, norms, and other factors.

    As our project developed over time, it became clear that we were creating a field guide. Much as a field guide to birds helps us look more closely at the birds we encounter on a walk through the woods, we hope this field guide might cause you to look at social media in a different way. To enliven the metaphor, we worked with the remarkable Fiammetta Ghedini of RIVA Illustrations to create a set of fancifully named avians to illustrate some of our favorite social media logics.

    This field guide is not just an invitation to look, but to discover: new social media logics, new ways of classifying or talking about social networks. We hope this book may be a living guide and hope that more authors might join us over time, either to document new logics or to challenge the categories we’ve created. The main message we hope you will take away from this project is not that ours is a correct way of mapping the space of social media, but that social media is vastly more complex and diverse than we often conceive of it.

    We celebrate this diversity consciously because we believe that having a too-limited understanding of what social media is leads us to a too-limited vision of what social media can be. There is a diverse space of social media outside of the shadow of the major platforms, and we believe it is there where the key to a different future lies. As Ruha Benjamin says, “imagination is a battleground.”1 Currently, we are living in the imagination of venture capitalists, a few corporations, and Mark Zuckerberg. To break out of it, we will have to imagine something different. We hope this project will be a valuable contribution to that process.

    — Ethan Zuckerman

    Continue Reading: Chapter 1: Civic Logic: Social media with opinion and purpose

    Footnotes

    1. 1.

      Ruha Benjamin, assoc. professor Afr. Am. Stud., Princeton Univ., How Race and Technology ‘Shape Each Other,’ keynote address at Emerson University Teach-In on Race (Oct. 18, 2019) (https://today.emerson.edu/2019/10/18/ruha-benjamin-how-race-and-technology-shape-each-other/#:~:text=With%20that%20a%20third%20provocation,of%20technology%20and%20social%20order [https://perma.cc/5ZFK-BB99]).

    Ethan Zuckerman is associate professor of public policy, information and communication at the University of Massachusetts at Amherst, director of the Initiative on Digital Public Infrastructure, and was the 2020-2021 visiting research scholar at the Knight Institute.

    Filed under

    Subscribe to our newsletter

    Get the latest news about our events, research, advocacy, litigation, and more in your inbox.